Indigenous People's Forced Climate Migration

After the recent COP29 meeting In Baku, Azerbaijan (29th Conference of the Parties to the United Nations Framework Convention on Climate Change), conversations surrounding representation, and which voices should be heard circulated. Recent statistics discovered 1,773 fossil fuel lobbyists attended COP29, versus a mere
170 Indigenous people, who had no real authority to make decisions at these official meetings. Their role includes advising those willing to hear them out for their expertise in matters related to climate change. However, it is evident that this expertise is often underestimated, and undervalued despite strong evidence that they hold the key to many climate change solutions

Eco-Tourism and Indigenous Erasure

Eco tourism is defined by environmentally responsible travel which appoints local people to have socio economic involvement, and values low visitor densities in areas desperately needing conservation.

However, there lacks specific guidelines and management deciding which vacations are classified as eco tourism, and many take advantage for profit, which inevitably leads to a fetishization of indigenous customs and culture. Stereotypical representations of indigenous people seep into organized tours, and many leave their world-widening vacation with the wrong impression of the true valuable role of indigenous people in the countries they inhabit worldwide. Often they must clear land in order to make room for tourists, which in turn destroys native housing and displaces native people from their resources. In India, the creation of tiger reserves to attract foreign tourist dollars has resulted in violent clashes and the eviction of scores of Adivasi Indigenous peoples from their homes. 

How Some Climate Change Solutions Cause More Harm Than Good

The investment and support for renewable energy is an essential way to mitigate climate change disasters, and bring a life saving network of power to those who do not have access to it. Yet, many do not realize the cost of this investment for those who have inhabited these lands for thousands of years. Mining for valuable minerals for batteries, solar panels, and electric vehicles is a large reason why many indigenous people are suffering. The mines are often close to tribal lands, more than 75% of lithium, copper, and nickel reserves in the U.S. are located within 25 miles of Indigenous lands. This has had a direct correlation with an increased risk in sexual violence for Native women, contaminated waterways, and leads to large amounts of air pollution that native people deal with every day. That has severe consequences for their livelihoods and maintenance of their practices and languages. The good news is Indigenous people have an International right to free, prior, and informed consent before decisions made about their territories are put into effect such as mining, solar, and hydroelectric projects. 

Indigenous Migration

Indigenous groups make up more than 4,000 of the 7,000 documented languages on Earth, even though they make up a small 6% of the entire population. While climate change is changing the landscape of lands they once loved and understood, vocabularies are are disappearing from dialects. An estimated 476 million Indigenous people dwell on lands that are home to 80 percent of the world’s biodiversity. They understand that they have a large responsibility to conserve and celebrate the beauties of nature in order to maintain their own cultural practices and keep their memories alive in the newer generations. Drought, an increase in nonedible grass for the livestock they raise, salty seawater mixed with the fresh water they rely on, and the quality of groundwater degrading are only some of the issues they face on a daily basis worldwide. We are not conserving land or biodiversity in a way that is equitable to Indigenous people whose culture, language, and way of life is at jeopardy when they leave ancestral lands. If they had access to the land they have owned for centuries, a lot of these issues would be manageable, and they wouldn't have to leave home. Equity is not considered enough when it comes to Indigenous rights, and many people refuse to look at the situation clearly. The forced migration taking place due to climate is not very different from the forced colonial migration Indigenous people have taken over the course of dark histories across the globe. It is essential that all policies take advantage of Indigenous knowledge and passion in order to change the narrative on climate change worldwide.

“There’s less rain, but if at least they had enough water from the rivers, if at least they had the access to the land, then they said they could have dealt with this,” GarcĂ­a says. “Climate change itself is not the main worry of people, but its effects are: The changes in water systems, deforestation, increased mining activities, all these things are having a larger impact, which are very subjective to each community.” (2024)

18 comments:

  1. Indigenous people unfortunately, as you discussed, have a long history of being overlooked and oppressed. There is no fair fight between a few hundred indigenous people and thousands of fossil fuel co leaders. It's a sad reality for sure.

    ReplyDelete
  2. You make a good point about where the materials come from for renewable energy. Making sure that they come from places that are not violating someone else's freedoms is key.

    ReplyDelete
  3. It is horrifying how much people just overlook others. These indigenous groups have the same right and anyone else to walk this earth, and yet are not treated the same and are suffering because of climate decisions that they often don’t have influence in. It is just a sad situation.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. Many people on our planet are overlooked despite having the same merit as everyone else. Until society stops basing morality on the color of your skin, and how westernized/colonialized you outwardly appear, lots of people will be left out of climate change discussions. This especially impacts policy making that could protect innocent people.

      Delete
  4. It’s very eye-opening to see how Indigenous communities, who hold invaluable knowledge, are being treated like this. Their insights aren’t just about preserving culture, but are essential for a sustainable and equitable progress.

    ReplyDelete
  5. This was an extremely informative blog post, and it is so upsetting given these awful statistics that it is not talked about more. The negative impacts that Indigenous people face from tourism alone are heartbreaking. I am really glad you chose to share this, and the research was extremely well presented.

    ReplyDelete
  6. The forced climate migration of Indigenous peoples, exacerbated by environmental degradation and exploitative practices like eco-tourism and resource extraction, highlights the urgent need for equitable policies that respect their rights and incorporate their invaluable knowledge in addressing climate change.

    ReplyDelete
  7. I remember talking in class about the dangers of climate change and forced migration, we had a very good long talk discussing how people will have to migrate eventually to find food because the growing conditions and soil will no longer be viable for producing food anymore, what a scary time.

    ReplyDelete
  8. The statistic that 75% of lithium, copper, and nickel reserves in the U.S. are located in 25 miles of indigenous land absolutely blew me away. I feel like this perspective is really important, illustrating how our attempted climate solutions are not bloodless. We have to be aware of all the impacts of our choices.

    ReplyDelete
  9. This comment has been removed by the author.

    ReplyDelete
  10. Great post, Olivia! My tribe in Papua, Indonesia, faces the same struggles. The government and companies take our land, leaving behind pollution from mining and toxic fertilizers from palm plantations. This harms nature and forces Indigenous people to leave their homes, becoming climate refugees. It’s heartbreaking, and I agree Indigenous voices must be heard and respected.

    ReplyDelete
  11. it never ceases to disgust me how people are treated that do not look or act or think like the average white male. It brings tears to my eyes to think of how indigenous people must feel when they see what kinds of things happen on their land.

    ReplyDelete
  12. Your post as well as the readings from Nomad Century have brought light to the environmental benefits of indigenous cultures, and it is disheartening how these groups continue to experience environmental injustices that drive them out of their homes with no safe outlets from climate change effects.

    ReplyDelete
  13. Climate inequality and racism are serious problems that need to be handled. We can hope that issues are handled in an equitable manner in the future.

    ReplyDelete
  14. I find it valuable to educate people on eco-tourism. I found that you included a vast amount of important information in this post. Eco-tourism is so common and even popularized in media yet hardly spoken about otherwise.

    ReplyDelete
  15. This world is full of environmental injustices which shouldn't happen. People that are in territories where they cannot live and have to move, should be a crime against human nature. Your post has good reasons on how to prevent climate migration and keep people in their home towns.

    ReplyDelete
  16. Most Americans think of "indigenous" people as Native Americans, but as you recognize there are indigenous people's all over the world - and they typically have long established and environmentally balanced relations with the Earth that we can learn from.

    ReplyDelete
  17. It is good to learn about the international law that gives indigenous peoples consultation and free, prior and informed consent (FPIC). And 4,000 - 7,000 languages from only 6% of the whole population is impressive but alarming to think how languages and cultures are becoming extinct when there are so many resources to help.

    ReplyDelete

How to Live More Sustainably

  Earth Day is on April 22nd each year. Do you have any traditions to celebrate it? With the recent passing of Earth Day it made me think o...